2008-12-17

A vexing vortex

This test, passed to me by The Sage Scribe, is very brief with only one question. But it's a very important one, especially considering the news of the past month. By giving an honest answer, you will discover where you stand morally.

The test features an unlikely, completely fictional situation in which you will have to make a decision. Remember that your answer needs to be honest, yet spontaneous. Please read slowly and give due consideration to each line.

THE SITUATION:

You are in Ottawa. There is chaos all around you caused by a huge mid-December storm with severe flooding. This is a flood of biblical proportions. You are a photo-journalist working for a major Canadian newspaper, and you're caught in the middle of this epic disaster. The situation is nearly hopeless. You're trying to shoot career-making photos.

There are houses and people swirling around you, some disappearing into the water of the Ottawa River. Nature is unleashing all of its destructive fury.

THE TEST:

Suddenly, you see four men in the water. They are fighting for their lives, trying not to be taken down with the debris. You move closer ... Somehow, the men look familiar ...

You suddenly realize who they are ... It's Stephen Harper, Stephane Dion, Jack Layton, and Gilles Duceppe!

You notice that the raging waters are about to take them under forever. You have two options: You can save lives or you can shoot a dramatic Pulitzer Prize-winning photo, documenting the death of the country's most powerful men at possibly one of Canada's most important historical moments!

THE QUESTION:

Here's the question, and please give an honest answer ...

Would you select high contrast colour film, or would you go with the classic simplicity of black and white?

6 comments:

coyote said...

Definitely black and white. Just like the question...

Kodak Tri-X Pan, pushed for contrast and extra grain, I think.

Milan said...

A photo-journalist shooting film in the middle of a disaster? Seems pretty unlikely.

I would snap a couple of RAW frames, then see what I could do to help them.

Woodsy said...

Shame on you IO for suggesting we take pictures. I would do the right thing. I would make a mini-movie with my camera and then go home and upload it on YouTube and hope it goes viral...

The Independent Observer said...

Shame on you, Woodsy! Your plan completely ignores marketing considerations such as poster, T-shirt, button and mousepad sales.

coyote said...

Milan: Hey. This would be art. It's an artistic decision. But not so long ago those photojournalist guys shot film in the middle of everything. Why not this?

Woodsy: I like the way you think...

IO: I like the way you think...

Milan said...

Forced to use film, I would probably go for something like Kodak's T-Max 400.

It is attractive, and much more forgiving of lighting and exposure problems than high contrast colour films tend to be.